Good judgment comes from experience and experience comes from poor judgment - Group Discussion

We all face situations daily when we are asked to take crucial decisions. We can only take the right decisions if we can judge the situation correctly. Taking the right decisions doesn’t mean overcoming a situation. By judging, you should be able to foresee any implications.

For:

- You learn from your mistakes. If every decision you take is in your favor, you may not learn as much.

- You acquire a good judgment with a poor judgment. This is a typical situation for people in research field.

- An experience is a mixture of good and bad. Only if you encounter bad can you sense and value good.

- No one is born with experiences. And no one is born perfect. Unless you don’t encounter a poor judgment, in essence you haven’t really experienced anything.

- You can’t succeed, if you can’t try. If you don’t try, you encircle yourself with a fear of taking incorrect decisions.

Against:

- Consider a doctors profession. He cannot afford to make a poor judgment.

- At times taking too many poor judgments can cost you a lot. That doesn’t leave you with a choice to experience anything.

- Good judgment comes from logic for most people. If you can carefully assess a situation, you can judge properly.

- Good judgment can also come from knowledge. You don’t have to experience poor judgments to take good judgments.

A judgment usually results in a decision. Good or bad at times cannot be predicted under unfavorable circumstances. We learn every day and we experience every day. These experiences nurture us to take decisions.