Should India curb all its ties with Pakistan?
Should India curb all its ties with Pakistan?
Since the time of partition the relations between India and Pakistan have always been strained. The relations went from bad to worse also because of the terrorist activities taken by the neighbouring countries on a recurring basis.
For:
- There has been continuous rise in the anti-social activities from Pakistan, unless these are activities are not stopped from there end, we should definitely stop all trades with Pakistan
- The Indian constituency has several times put forward the plea of friendship in front of Pakistan, but there has been no response from their side and on the other hand the terrorist activities have always increased
- The huge dispute between India and Pakistan has been mainly because of the Kashmir dispute, unless this dispute is not resolved till then it would be best for us to curtail our relations with the neighbouring country
Against:
- Discontinuing all the ties with Pakistan is not the solution, the war is not with the entire Pakistan but just with a limited few people like the politicians and the intelligence agencies. So why should the innocent people be also dragged in between and punished for what they have not done
- During partition, a lot of families were also parted and still they are bearing the brunt of partition and by curbing the relations they will never be able to meet up with their rest of the families.
Conclusion:
- We should be limiting our relations, but curbing the relations completely is not a solution until all the kind of illegal and anti-social activities are stopped from their end.
Discussion
- RE: Should India curb all its ties with Pakistan? -jaish rajawat (08/26/14)
- taking decision hurriedly to curb all relations might result in devastation.as haste makes waste but however we can't keep our eyes close on various inhuman acts of Pakistan.we need to develop a string line of defence ,threat them that if line of patience is crossed even by inch now,we'll forget our harmony and peaceful image...calling off secretary level talk by modi govt is good indicative for showing them our dominance and getting fed up of their lies and indecent moves.
- RE: Should India curb all its ties with Pakistan? -MOHAN JANGA (08/19/14)
- Dear Sir,
Does Losing trade relation with Pakistan which amounts to a small amount of 400 millions compared with 142 Billion USD of our Global exports matter much?
We must curd relation with Pakistan. - RE: Should India curb all its ties with Pakistan? -MOHAN JANGA (08/18/14)
- Dear Sir,
It has been a high time the relation with Pakistan should have been broken. Simple factor is we have the unwanted J&K matter raked up since 1947 when the King of J&K opted to join India. Terror attacks etc is known. We had 3 wars which can't be over looked.
But, these are all known factors, and these are all to be put on one basket and declare Pakistan as an ANTI India country and an Enemy of India.
No one can have goody goody relation with an enemy country under a Diplomatic umbrella.
Regards - RE: Should India curb all its ties with Pakistan? -Rajani Sharma (12/14/13)
- For:
- Seeing the sacrifices made by the soldiers and keeping the national pride in mind, India should curb all the ties with Pakistan. As, Pakistan has always given excuses for his deeds and from the history, it is evident that, whenever Indians have tried to approach Pakistan to resolve the matter, they have always betrayed us.
- Pakistan has always taken advantage of the sincerity and friendliness shown by India in many ways.
- Pakistan shouldn't be trusted as whenever we raised our hands towards them for friendship, they have always betrayed us and sent terrorists to infiltrate our motherland and to bring violence in the country.
- Pakistan is promoting terrorism in India by providing education, training and shelter to terrorists and making them to attack Indian cities to create fear in people's mind. This kind of decision only will enhance India's image on the international grounds.
- Pakistan again and again fighting and making Kashmir an issue and the talks of overtaking it from India, should also be the reason for India to curb all the ties with Pakistan. Pakistan's policy of creating social unrest and religious riots makes it difficult to come on the same page with Pakistan.
- The move to curb all the ties will help people in Kashmir and other areas to be relaxed from the forces from the other side of border and they will feel more safe and secure. This will also help India to handle the terrorist activities from all the ends.
- Pakistan is not ready to normalize the bilateral economic relations as well as personal relations with India. If Pakistan is not ready to give the respect that India deserves it is better to break all the ties with them.
Against:
- Pakistan has potential for high trade and resource sharing between the two countries that might get affected, if India breaks the ties with Pakistan. The estimated trade between these two countries is around US$400 million. In case of India taking any action to curb all the ties then it might affect or hamper the liberalization of trade. It will also affect the economy of both the countries and the industries that are dependent on it.
- Indian Government extracts lots of revenue from the Bollywood industry for the entertainment purpose and the entertainment sector is having big market in Pakistan. Bollywood movies are released in Pakistan and generate good amount of revenue. If there comes any differences between the two countries then it will effect the revenue generation of India as well and might bring losses to Indian Government.
- This kind of decision of breaking all the ties might result in social unrest and create state of panic between the Muslim communities who are living in India. It can further harm the sentiments as it can also create a wall between both the countries and the communication might become troublesome for the people living in both the countries.
- Lots of projects are going on in Pakistan like Project of gas pipeline that is from Iran to India via Pakistan which is under consideration and if such decision is taken then these kinds of ties might come under the scanner which might harm Indian economy. - RE: Should India curb all its ties with Pakistan? -Ketan (10/15/13)
Should India curb all its ties with Pakistan
A mutual understanding between the two countries is very essential. India took many steps, and has been trying to resolve various issues with Pakistan through diplomatic channels, what have we received in return?........violations, border infiltration, decapitation event like 26/11, killing of Indian prisoner in jails. These things are not doing any good with diplomatic ties.
Indian is tolerating Pakistan’s nonsense on various issues and they have all time lied white. But if we break the ties, situation may go worse and it may lead to one more war. Pakistan is our neighbor nation and if we build good relation with them it will lead to build a great nation.
Peace can only be sough if India and Pakistan talk in truthful and positive gesture. Every country is surrounded by society, which comprise of good people, peace, development, new technology and better life style. But one major problem for both countries is ‘Terrorism’. Every home consists of Cockroaches and Pest, just to kill them you can’t burn the house, same way breaking of relation is not option. But India should take some necessary steps to end this conflict and maintain a good relationship with Pakistan.
We are always in favor of harmony and peace with every country so keep seeking solutions instead of curb all ties with Pakistan.
